top of page

Yummy Lobster Pickle Sandwich

Lobster Sandwich

Having a lobster sandwich has been on my mind since day one of the opening of the 2016 lobster season. I love rich juicy lobster meat lathered up with mayonnaise and pickles surrounded by sourdough bread. Believe me, I couldn't wait to crank out this new recipe. The only thing I need is a few lobsters...

Brian to the rescue! Brian's found his bugs on opening night at Mission Bay. He and his kayak circumvented the territorial water's of the bay and found his little patch right up against the jetty rocks. But the wind and the water was far from calm. It was a gusty move, but it paid off in a big way. Brian limited out. So when he handed over a few lobster tails, I didn't have to think twice. So Brian this lobster sandwich is for you!

california spiny lobster

Lucky Brian and his bugs!

Rock Lobster Pickle Sandwich (makes 2 sandwiches)

2 lobster tails

½ bundle of green onions, chopped

4 stalks of celery, chopped

1 red bell pepper

1 tablespoon fresh dill chopped

½ lime, juiced

2 tablespoons pickled pepper rings.

2 tablespoons of the juice from pepper rings (vinegar)

2 sliced dill pickles

5 tablespoons of mayonnaise

4 slices sourdough bread

Kosher salt

Coarse black pepper

2 tablespoons olive oil

Making The Lobster Sandwich

1. Start by toasting the sliced bread.

2. Next, begin roasting the red bell pepper by placing it on top of a stove top flame. Keep rotating it to blacken its skin. Then, peel the skin off and remove the pepper's core and seeds. Cut it into halves, and set them aside.

3. Now, take the lobsters tail and cut open their top shells, exposing the meat (don't remove the meat). Drizzle in olive oil, then season with salt and pepper.

4. Finally, begin microwaving the tails, starting for one minute. Now, check for doneness. If more cooking is required, only cook for 10 second intervals until the center of the tails are no longer opaque. Don't over cook the tails!! In the end, extract the meat, and then coarsely chop.

5. Grab a mixing bowl and add the lobster, celery, green onions, pepper rings, pepper ring juice, fresh dill, lime juice and mayonnaise, and then mix.

6. Ok, now spread mayonnaise on the both slices of toasted bread, and sprinkle a little black pepper on the mayonnaise. Now lay a slab of roasted red pepper on one slice, and then add the lobster mixture on top of the red pepper. Finally, add the second slice of bread and add a slice of pickle on top of that. Lastly, place tooth picks through the pickles and through the sandwich. Cut in half and serve.


Here's a great way to support Fisherman's Belly. Use our amazon links to purchase items you may need. You don't pay extra but, Amazon sends us a small commission on your purchase. Just click on the links below to take a look and shop around. Thanks, Yanni


➤ 30 Day Free Amazon Prime Membership

KITCHEN GADGETS & INGREDIENTS FOR THIS RECIPE 🌶​ ➤ 12-inch Chef's Knife ➤ Wusthof Pro Cook’s Knife 12-inch ➤ Bread Cutting Serrated Culinary 10-inch Knife ➤ Ex-Large Bamboo Cutting Board 18"x14" ➤ 24" Round Hard Wood Cutting Board ➤ Pyrex 1-cup & 2-cup Measuring Cups ➤ Olive Oil Dispenser Bottle 16-oz ➤ Kirkland Organic Extra Virgin Olive Oil 2L ➤ Pro Stainless Steel Mixing Bowl Set of 6 ➤ Fish Prepping Pan (13"x9"x2") ➤ Pyrex 2-Quart Glass Bakeware With Lid $10 ➤ Panasonic Microwave Genius Sensor

PHOTOGRAPHY EQUIPMENT USED 🎥 ➤ Canon EOS 70D Food Photography & Video ➤ GoPro HERO4 Black

Screen Shot 2016-06-26 at 5.46.09 PM.png

Meet The



I'm a fisherman and a cook, and I love to do both. My name is Yanni and welcome to my website, Fisherman's Belly. Here, using your fresh fish and everyday ingredients, you can learn to cook hand-crafted easy fish recipes. 

See you on the water and in the kitchen. Yanni

Stay Updated SUBSCRIBE

Sign up now for the latest updates and yummy recipes sent straight to your inbox.   

Have A Fish Cooking


Thanks for submitting your question. I'll get back with you as soon as possible. Yanni

fried fish sandwich.jpeg
bottom of page