top of page

Stuffed Lobster

Both Greek and California fishermen have spiny lobsters along their coastlines. That's why I'm introducing a recipe straight from a Greek fisherman's kitchen, stuffed Greek lobster. This recipe bakes stuffed lobster halves filled with chunks of lobster, homemade tomato sauce and feta cheese. This flavor combination is loved by all Greeks.

Like having lobster for breakfast? Try my lobster omelet, it's a great way to start your day!

This video-recipe is easy to follow and full of tips and tricks. After watching the video, you'll have the confidence to make this dish. All you need some fresh whole lobsters, good tomatoes, canned or fresh, and good Greek feta cheese. Go ahead and surprise everyone with this Greek stuffed lobster dish!

Catch and cook lobsters

Mikey's catch in Mission Bay a week before the 2020 season closer.

southern California spiny lobster

Here's my personal best spiny lobster at just over 8 pounds, out of Santa Monica Bay.

Stuffed Lobster (serves 4-6)

2-ea 2 pound lobsters, whole

1 can crushed tomatoes, 28ounces

2 whole fresh tomatoes, hand grated

3-5 cloves of garlic, finely diced

1 whole onion, medium dice

2-3 tablespoons of olive oil

Pinch of oregano

Kosher salt/coarse black pepper

1 tablespoon of sugar, optional

¼ pound of feta cheese, crumbled

1 cup of fresh basil

greek lobster recipe

Start Making The Greek Stuffed Lobster

1. When you're ready, start by parboiling your lobsters whole, in salted water. What's salted water? Use enough salt so the water tastes like the sea! Boil both lobsters at 5.5 minutes per 2 pounds of lobster. When done, refrigerate the lobsters until needed.

2. Next, start creating the tomato sauce while first sautéing the onions in olive oil. After 5 minutes add the garlic and lower the heat slightly to ensure the garlic doesn't burn. Saute the onions and garlic until completely translucent then set aside.

3. Now, in a separate pot, add the canned and fresh grated tomatoes, plus a ½ cup of fresh basil. Add a pinch of oregano, salt and pepper. Taste the sauce. If more sweetness is required, then add a tablespoon of sugar. Cook over a medium high heat. Remember to constantly stir by the tomato mixture to prevent the sauce from burning at the bottom of the pan. Finally, cook the tomato mixture until it's reduced by half. Now, add the sautéd onions and garlic to the tomato mixture while lowering the heat to a simmer. Continue to simmer for another 15 minutes.

Prep The Lobsters

4. In the mean while, use a large chef's knife and cut the cooled lobsters in half. Remove the tail meat and discard the remaining entrails while leaving the lobster shell intact. Now, chop the tail meat into large chunks. Tip: To throughly clean the inside of the lobster shells, sprinkle coarse Kosher salt inside the shells and wipe clean with a paper towel.

5. Preheat the oven at 450F for 15 minutes or so, then lower to 375F just before placing lobsters inside oven.

6. When the tomato sauce is cooked, allow it to cool for a few minutes. Then add the chopped lobster and mix. Spoon out the mixture into the entire halved lobster shells. In the end, add sprinkle crumbled feta cheese on top of stuffed lobster halves. Now place the stuffed lobster halves onto an oven pan and bake at 375F for 10 minutes.

7. Serve the lobster halves on a platter, and finally garnish with fresh hand-cut basil. Enjoy!

NEED SOME KITCHEN STUFF? 🙂 Here's a great way to support Fisherman's Belly. Use our

amazon links to purchase items you may need. You don't

pay extra but, Amazon sends us a small commission on

your purchase. Just click on the links below to take a look

and shop around. Thanks, Yanni

___________________________________________________________ ➤ 30 Day Free Amazon Prime Membership

KITCHEN GADGETS & INGREDIENTS FOR THIS RECIPE 🌶 ➤ Cento San Marzano Organic Peeled Tomatoes 6-pac 28-oz ➤ Mercer Culinary 12-inch Chef's Knife ➤ Wusthof Pro Cook’s Knife 12-inch ➤ Ex-Large Bamboo Cutting Board 18"x14" ➤ Stock Pot Stainless Steel 20-quart w/Lid ➤ Real Greek Feta 7-oz

PHOTOGRAPHY EQUIPMENT USED 🎥 ➤ Canon EOS 70D Food Photography & Video ➤ GoPro HERO4 Black

Screen Shot 2016-06-26 at 5.46.09 PM.png

Meet The



I'm a fisherman and a cook, and I love to do both. My name is Yanni and welcome to my website, Fisherman's Belly. Here, using your fresh fish and everyday ingredients, you can learn to cook hand-crafted easy fish recipes. 

See you on the water and in the kitchen. Yanni

Stay Updated SUBSCRIBE

Sign up now for the latest updates and yummy recipes sent straight to your inbox.   

Have A Fish Cooking


Thanks for submitting your question. I'll get back with you as soon as possible. Yanni

fried fish sandwich.jpeg
bottom of page